Reflections from Hilton Als

Reflections from Hilton Als

Brilliant New Yorker critic Hilton Als discusses the impact of photographer Richard Avedon’s work on 1960s America.

Esteemed author, educator and New Yorker critic Hilton Als—who earned an honorary degree from RISD at Commencement 2016—returned to campus on Thursday, October 26 to deliver the RISD Museum’s 2017 Gail Silver Memorial Lecture. In introducing the Pulitzer Prize-winning critic to the sizable crowd, Museum Director John Smith extolled his “provocative contributions to discourses on theater, identity, sexuality, class and race in America.”

Als says that writer James Baldwin (shown here in a contact sheet from the studio of his friend Richard Avedon) was a huge influence on him as a young man.

During his talk in the RISD Auditorium, Als read from selected essays he has written for The New Yorker, which began publishing his lyrical prose in 1989. Delivered in his melodious voice, they sounded like pure poetry.

Als began with a short piece inspired by the recent spate of sexual misconduct allegations in the news and America’s longstanding complicity in “ignoring what should not be ignored. This is America,” he said, “where we like to forget, but don’t.” He noted that our terrible silences (in response to everything from the AIDS epidemic to queer-bashing to systemic racism) are ultimately challenged by the artists among us, who dare to change the discourse.

“This is America, where we like to forget, but don’t.”

“For, if they take you in the morning, they will be coming for us that night,” Als intoned. He was quoting An Open Letter to My Sister, Angela Y. Davis by the late, great writer James Baldwin, whose influence on the young Als was enormous. As a kid growing up in Brooklyn, he confessed, he frequently ditched school to pore over art books at the public library. He was particularly enthralled by Nothing Personal, a 1964 collaboration between Baldwin and celebrated photographer Richard Avedon.

A spread from Nothing Personal featuring Fabian (left), whom Als describes as "the essence of male arrogance."

Affectionately referring to the duo as “Dick and Jimmy,” Als devoted the rest of his talk to Crime and Punishment, his essay about their lifelong friendship and the impact of their work on his life. Baldwin and Avedon met in high school—a black man and a Jew, both outsiders peering in at mainstream American culture. Like Als, they both were raised by distant, difficult fathers and loving mothers.

Nothing Personal features Avedon’s piercing black-and-white portraits, some of which Als showed during his talk: the intense gaze of Martin Luther King III as a boy thrust into the spotlight, a deflated Marilyn Monroe whose dedication to projecting her public persona had momentarily flagged, the sexy but menacing pop star Fabian, described by Als as “the essence of male arrogance.”


An Avedon family portrait of three generations of Martin Luther Kings.

In a friendly Q+A session after his reading, Als discussed his beginnings as a thinker and a theater critic attending performances with the late poet Owen Dodson, who would become his mentor. He bantered with a RISD student who praised his Instagram account but knew nothing about the advent of Polaroid photography. “Instagram is just an excuse for not writing,” he quipped, commenting on their age difference by adding, “I was already drunk and on unemployment when you were born.”

Als went on to recount his early, “uncensored” submissions as a freelance writer and his start at The New Yorker. He was offered a job by famed editor Tina Brown but was so awed by her presence (and confused by her accent) that when she told him to “see the money people,” he left the office and ended up working for Vibe for two years. When he next saw Brown, she was more explicit: “Hilton, I’m hiring you.”

Does the influential critic consider himself an advocate for the arts? Als responded without hesitation: “I advocate for thinking and reflection.”

—Simone Solondz / Als image by Jo Sittenfeld MFA 08 PH

Related stories

Sikander Imagines New Frontiers

As RISD’s 2016 Kirloskar Visiting Scholar, multidisciplinary artist Shahzia Sikander MFA 95 PT/PR is sharing insights about Islam, collaboration and multiculturalism through a series of public programs.

Making Something from Nothing

Artist and urban interventionist Theaster Gates talks about the transformative power of art at the 2015 Gail Silver Memorial Lecture.

Patti Smith Shares Her Power

Even if you weren’t privy to the rebellious start of the New York punk scene, chances are you’d recognize the distinctive voice of legendary artist Patti Smith.